No posts on this blog covered published Appellate Division decisions issued in August. Thus, to catch up, this post will be a “lightning round” of brief summaries of the six August published opinions of the Appellate Division.
State v. Fox, ___ N.J. Super. ___ (App. Div. 2026). Judge Jacobs’s opinion in this case posed and answered the question presented in his opening paragraph. “This appeal presents a question of first impression: whether a trial judge may require a jury to reach unanimity before requesting playback of trial testimony. We conclude the trial judge misapplied her discretion by requiring juror unanimity before further considering an initial request for testimony playback.” Finding plain error, the panel vacated defendant’s convictions for fourth-degree operating a motor vehicle during a period of license suspension and remanded for a new trial.
State v. Hubbard, ___ N.J. Super. ___ (App. Div. 2026). This opinion by Judge Jablonski comprised seven appeals. It involved another “issue of first impression, whether a county prosecutor must disclose substantive details about a police department’s pending internal affairs (“IA”) investigation to a defendant in a criminal case in which the investigating officer was involved before that investigation is completed.” The Law Division required disclosure, but the Appellate Division found that to be a mistaken exercise of discretion and reversed.
Fioravante v. Fioravante, ___ N.J. Super. ___ (App. Div. 2026). This appeal addressed the Family Part’s award of attorneys’ fees and sanctions in three consolidated appeals. Speaking through Judge Auguostini, the Appellate Division reversed the fee award and remanded for a more complete analysis of the fee issues. The panel also reversed the sanctions, but a different reason: the safe harbor letter sent by the party to whom sanctions were awarded was insufficient.
Gray v. University Hospital, ___ N.J. Super. ___ (App. Div. 2026). The question in this appeal, as phrased by Judge Bishop-Thompson’s opinion, was “whether N.J.S.A. 2A:23B-12 requires a party-appointed arbitrator to disclose prior employment of over twenty years as corporate counsel for a former client, who is not involved in this litigation, and whether this circumstance creates a conflict of interest.” The panel held that the arbitrator had no such duty because there was no conflict of interest on those facts, affirming the ruling of the Law Division.
Tennant v. Pleasantville Bd. of Educ., ___ N.J. Super. ___ (App. Div. 2026). This was a tragic case. As Judge Currier described it, the matter involved a ten-year-old boy who was struck by a bullet intended for someone else while attending a high school football game. The issue was “whether defendant Pleasantville Board of Education (PBOE) can be civilly liable … under the New Jersey Civil Rights Act (NJCRA), N.J.S.A. 10:6-2(c) and the New Jersey Constitution, Article I, ¶ 1 under a state-created danger theory.” The BPOE had sought summary judgment, which the Law Division denied. The Appellate Division, however, reversed, holding that the state-created danger doctrine did not apply.
Estate of Sahar v. 301 Union Street, LLC, ___ N.J. Super. ___ (App. Div. 2026). This appeal was from a jury verdict for plaintiff against the defendant nursing home after plaintiff fell at defendant’s premises. Defendant offered several arguments, including that defendant was not a nursing home covered by the Nursing Home Responsibilities and Rights of Residents Act, N.J.S.A. 30:13-1 et seq., on which plaintiff relied, and that there were evidentiary errors and improper jury charges that resulted in excessive damages. Judge Rose’s lengthy opinion for the Appellate Division rejected those arguments and the panel affirmed the result below.